Pop songs are built so the voice is the fingerprint. Listen accordingly.
Pop is the lane where the vocal is almost always the intended clue. Production on a pop record exists to deliver a voice, which means the arrangement, the reverb and the layering are all decisions about how that voice should feel. If you listen to the instruments first on this lane, you are reading the packaging instead of the product.
The useful features are specific. Is the vocal double-tracked? Is the chorus stacked with harmonies or left bare? Is there a noticeable reverb, and does it sound like a room or a plate? Is the voice processed with obvious pitch correction, or does it slip between notes? Each answer narrows the era, because each production choice became standard at a different time.
The second clue is song structure. Pop is formulaic in a helpful way. An intro, a verse, a pre-chorus, a chorus all arrive within a predictable first half minute, and the place the clip starts tells you which section of the song you are hearing. A clip that begins on a pre-chorus build is a different kind of song from one that begins on a cold verse.
The third clue is the hook itself. Pop hooks are designed to be memorable, which means a six-second rung should be enough to catch one. If I reach twenty seconds and still cannot hum the melody back, I have misunderstood the lane and should switch strategies.
My current weakness on this lane is modern pop, because the production is so clean that the room-tone clues I rely on are missing. I am working on it in the unlimited mode, where I can play twenty modern-pop rounds in a row and let the features repeat until they are familiar.
The lane also rewards knowing the difference between a hook and a riff. A hook is sung and a riff is played, and pop is built around the first, so confusing the two costs guesses.